Business model innovation challenge for creative sectors Monday, 8 June 2015
Sectors at the core of innovation – such as architecture, design and the gaming industry – struggle with innovating their business models because of a lower interest in business aspects, with respect to artistic ones, and a too strong focus on customer preferences. New PhD research by Maria Rita Micheli of Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus University (RSM) reveals companies from all sectors can learn from their mistakes. Companies can innovate their business models by not investing all of their resources in getting a central position in their networks, but instead getting a position to get relevant information to enhance the innovative process. Moreover, employees and managers’ goals have to be aligned and work together on the innovative process. This helps the company to implement long-term changes, acquire new capabilities and even re-structure the organisation for better ways of working, or for greater efficiency.
The creative sector was hit hardest during the financial crisis, and innovating business models was a matter of urgency. Yet many companies in the creative industry still do not know how to innovate themselves to make the most of business opportunities. In her dissertation Business model innovation: a journey across managers’ attention and inter – organizational networks, Maria Rita Micheli found that the creative minds of artists might be unaware of their current business model, and not interested in innovating it. Their main focus is on artistic innovation. In addition, the creative sector contains a large proportion of very small companies with small capital and managers might decide not to invest resources to spend on external consultants who could help. And lastly, there is no other industry in which customer’s reactions to the end product shape business models as much as in the creative sector. Companies might make the mistake to excessively focus on customers' requests instead of implementing their innovation plans.
“The main focus of creative minds is on artistic innovation - not on innovating their business model.”
Learning from innovation mistakes
By looking at mistakes made by companies in the creative sector, organisations in all other sectors can learn and do better when innovating their business models. First, they should not invest all their resources in getting a central position in the network’ is missing, says Micheli. Instead, companies should make sure they leverage on the networks to acquire the information they need to change their business model. Also, businesses should encourage employees to be eager to learn. They must keep their eyes open for new trends in the market and for opportunities to improve the business model. Finally, they have to understand that investing in these goals is worth the effort, despite the initial difficulties and negative reactions from clients.
To make business model innovation work, a company needs knowledge of its partners, familiarity with its clients, and the support of its employees; it is a journey across managers’ attention and inter-organisational networks.
Micheli will defend her dissertation at Erasmus University Rotterdam on Friday 12 June 2015 at 9:30 in the Forumzaal in the M Building. Her promoter is Prof. Justin Jansen and her co-promoter is Dr. Luca Berchicci Other members of the Doctoral Committee are Prof. Charles Baden – Fuller, Prof. William Ocasio, Prof. Harry Barkema, Prof. Jan van den Ende, and Prof. Taco Reus.
Business model innovation is an emergent area of research with the potential to re-structure the pillars of strategy research. Despite the growing interest, the process of how business models change is not clearly described. In fact, only a few empirical studies explain the antecedents of business model innovation and people do not have a clear understanding of how companies combine external knowledge with internal capabilities for innovating. In addition, scholars have not been able to describe the steps that managers undertake to innovate their business models. Maria Rita Micheli’s dissertation aims at addressing these gaps.
Micheli finds that networks in which companies are embedded function as a learning environment for stimulating business model innovation. At the same time, she highlights specific network dynamics, characterising business model innovation as a different phenomenon to other innovation processes. Micheli also addresses the analysis of the business model innovation process, showing the relevance of managers’ attention. Finally, she shows the importance of managers’ goal orientation, looking at how they are influenced by environmental and organisational contingencies. These findings derive from qualitative and quantitative studies conducted in the field of creative industries.
Micheli’s dissertation has the potential to contribute to research along three dimensions: (1) shedding light on the process of business model innovation, (2) exploring the relevance of managers’ attention for business model innovation, (3) exploring the effectiveness of different business model innovation strategies.
About Maria Rita Micheli
Maria Rita Micheli, born in Italy (1985) completed her bachelor and master degrees in management at Bocconi University in Milan. After completing her master degree in 2009, she worked as research assistant in the management and technology department at Bocconi University. Micheli started her PhD trajectory in 2010 in the Department of Strategic Management & Entrepreneurship. During her PhD, she spent the fall quarter 2013 at Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University. She was affiliated both with the management and organisations department, and the Northwestern Institute on Complex Systems. Her research interests span from social networks to attentional based view, which she combined for exploring processes of business model innovation. The empirical field of her PhD project is the Dutch creative industry, with a special interest in architecture, design and gaming companies. In her work, she combines qualitative and quantitative methods, showing the relevance of managers and inter-organisational networks for the innovation of companies’ business models. She will soon start as Assistant Professor in Strategy at IESEG School of Management in Paris. In addition to her researching activities, Micheli is passionate about sport, cinema and dance.